Then Vs. Now

Louise SuggsI was very sad to learn that Louise Suggs passed away on Friday.   I’ve been a fan of the LPGA since I started playing golf and Ms. Suggs’ legacy, as a feisty competitor and quick-witted personality, is legendary.  But it’s not her golf I’ll miss – there’s great golf today – it’s her personality.  Players today just don’t seem to have the same spontaneity and, well, fun.

Ms. Suggs once said:  “Golf is very much like a love affair – if you don’t take it seriously, it’s no fun. But if you do, it breaks your heart.”   Can anyone picture Inbee Park saying this?

I’m not getting on her case – she’s a great ambassador of the game.  But today’s players are products of the times.  They seem to be unable to take golf seriously AND have fun.  They have “peeps” that manage them, they receive extensive PR and communications training, they have to consider their sponsors in all they do.  Their lives are conducted like mini-corporations.

Compare today’s player to Amy Alcott, who during a postgame interview was asked what her favorite sitcom was.  She said All in the Family, then proceeded to sing the entire theme song.  “Boy the way Glenn Miller played….”  The network aired the entire song.  Why?  Because it was hysterically funny and spontaneous!

Or Meg Mallon grabbing her towel off her bag and waving it in surrender after Dottie Pepper bladed a sand wedge into the cup, thus ending Meg’s chances at victory.  Would, or could, any of today’s players be that spontaneous or funny?  Especially after having just lost?

But the best example of how our athletes have changed is at the Nabisco Dinah Shore (one of 4 major tournaments now called the ANA Inspiration).  Amy Alcott was so overwhelmed with joy when she won in 1988, she spontaneously jumped into the pond at the 18th hole.  The crowd roared.  Today’s winners continue this tradition, but they do so with embroidered towels, TV cameras placed in perfect positions, and a predetermined list of who’s jumping into the pond with them.  And the commentators talk about the pond jump continually for all 4 days of the tournament.  While still fun to watch, it has nothing to do with genuine joy.

Maybe today’s players, with their mini-corporations, etc. just have more to lose so they’re more guarded.   But I’d love to see some free-wheeling, nothing-to-lose personality come along.



  1. Teri August 10, 2015 at 11:04 pm - Reply

    As someone who attended the Dinah in 1988 when Amy Alcott jumped in the pond, Patty, I know exactly what you mean. It’s all ratings, and viewership, and money today. When Ms. Suggs, and the incredible women who formed the LPGA back in 1950, played golf, they were about showing the world they could compete-which they did in skirts! That is their legacy. Our women pros can compete today because Louise Suggs and the early LPGA family paved the way with their skill, their athleticism and their incredible personalities.

  2. Sheri August 11, 2015 at 5:22 pm - Reply

    So true. And sadly, I think this “image management” and lack of genuine, unchoreographed human response/interaction pervades many of our lives. Maybe we can all get a little more “real”!

Leave A Comment